How we compare

Our method in plain terms

We compile and verify pricing and plan terms from the providers' own published pages on a regular refresh cycle. We do not do hands on testing, we do not run a lab, and we never claim to. Our work is research and arithmetic. We read what each provider publishes, record the fees and terms in a standard format, check those records again on our refresh cycle, and publish the results in comparison tables.

This approach has a clear strength and a clear limit. Every figure can be traced back to a provider page that any reader can visit. We cannot tell you how a device feels on the wrist or how a speaker sounds in a particular home. For questions like those, we point readers to provider trial periods and money back guarantee terms, which we include in our tables when a provider publishes them.

The fields we score

Each provider is scored out of 10 from published fields only. We use the same fields for every provider, and we apply the same scoring approach to each one. The fields are:

A score is a summary of those published fields. The table itself is always available beside the score, so you can weigh the fields that matter most to your family. One family may care most about the lowest first year cost. Another may care most about GPS coverage for a parent who walks daily.

How total first year cost works

Total first year cost is the figure we built this site around. We calculate it in a consistent way for every provider. The total includes equipment plus activation plus shipping where it applies, plus 12 months of monitoring, plus 12 months of fall detection where the table shows the with fall detection total.

A system can carry a modest monthly price and still have a high first year total if the equipment price and activation fee are large. Another system can carry a higher monthly price and a lower first year total if equipment is included and activation is waived. Showing the first year total makes that difference visible at a glance.

Where a provider offers fall detection as an optional add on, our tables can show two totals. One total covers the base plan for the first year. The other total covers the first year with fall detection included. Both totals use the same method, and the table labels each total clearly.

Fall detection can contact the monitoring center after many falls, even when the wearer cannot press the button. No fall detection system catches every fall. We include that limit wherever we describe fall detection, because families should understand what the feature can do and where its limits sit.

What the Prices verified date means

Each price carries a Prices verified date. That date shows the month and year we last checked each provider's published pricing. We recheck prices on a regular refresh cycle, and we update the date when we complete a new check.

Prices can change between checks. A provider can raise a fee, end a promotion, or change a plan structure at any time. If a figure here differs from a figure on a provider site, the provider figure governs your purchase. We welcome correction emails through our Contact page.

How commissions fit in

Commissions never decide our rankings or scores. Some providers pay us a commission when a reader buys through a link on this site, and some pay us nothing at all. The scoring fields and approach stay the same in both cases. Our Disclosure page explains the commission setup in full.

Corrections and updates

If you spot a fee that looks out of date, please email us through the Contact page with the provider name and the page where you saw the new figure. We will check the provider source, update the table if the change checks out, and refresh the verified date.